American Idol - The Girls

Asia'h - No. I don't get why contestants try to do Whitney Houston songs. It just never works! As always, my Simon is right.

Kady Malloy - Why is she singing another slow song?? I don't like the song choice and it's pitchy. Kady's going home this week.

Amanda Overmyer - She should have rocked that song. She didn't. Has she given up? Randy and Paula liked it? Simon thought it was "fantastic?" She's got some kind of bee in her bonnet, doesn't she? What's she mad about? Danny Noriega?!

Carly Smithson - I continue to like her despite the songs she chooses and the outfits she wears.

Kristy Lee Cook - Don't eff up a Journey song, Kristy! She can't hit those high notes - but I didn't hate the rest of it.

Ramiele - I think she's such a pretty girl. I love this song ("fancy a bit o' Phil, Lisa?"). I liked it ok.

Brooke White - A little like last week with her sitting there, isn't it? I do like her voice, tho and I thought she did a good job. Good song for her.

Syesha Mercado - Oh no - Whitney song. Eh.

1. Brooke White
2. Carly Smithson
3. Amanda Overmyer
4. Syesha
5. Ramiele
6. Kristy Lee Cook

and going home this week:
7. Asia'h
8. Kady