American Idol - The Girls

OMG, all I can think of when they just panned the guys was "THAT'S A WIG, DUDE!" lol

Ok, up first: Carly Smithson. The Irish girl. Is she pitchy? I think she's pitchy! She needed a bra. Parts of it were good - but all in all....not great. Randy says a'right. Paula says nothing. Simon says better than last week but not her best yet. Says she's an incredible singer - girl to beat.

Syesha Mercado - She's a good singer, but I find her very boring. Why do they pick such slooowwwwwwww songs? Oh good - Simon and I are on track tonight.

Brooke White - The guitar was kinda cool, but it got in the way of her vocals. It was ok. She's not a favorite of mine. Simon "absolutely loved it!" Huh! Go Figure.

Ramiele - I love her. I don't think that song was the best choice. Altho in a "best version you ever heard at a small town wedding" way it was GREAT! I don't think she's in jeopardy of going anywhere.

Kristy Lee Cook - she was ok. Better than last week for sure.

Amanda Overmyer. I like her. If someone gave her a GOOD dye job and cut she would be so much better looking. Simon, as usual is right on! Oh my - Paula is giving her fashion advice. Wha???

Alaina Whitaker - Girlfriend needed a pair of Spanx. Her lipgloss was nice. It was ok.

Oh no - this girl is alll over the place. She was awful. What's her name? Alexandrea. Randy and Paula were too nice. Simon. Oh, my Simon. Always right.

Kady Malloy - yeah, I agree with the judges.

Asia'h - No. No. I like her, but this song is not right. She can't hit notes. Oh no. and what's up with those extensions?

I'm finding it hard to rank the girls since I don't feel like there were any standouts. Here it goes anyway:

1. Carly Smithson
2. Ramiele
3. Brooke White
4. Asia'h
5. Amanda Overmyer
6. Alaina Whitaker
7. Kristy Lee Cook
8. Syesha

and my bottom 2:
9. Alexandrea
10. Kady Malloy